Dinner Menu

For PDF copy: Dinner Menu – Fall & Winter 2016/17

Welcome to Fish Tales Restaurant, where old friends gather and new friends meet. Established in 2000, we are proud to offer you the best dining in the Lake Wisconsin area. Fresh ingredients, delicious flavors and a great experience in traditional Wisconsin supper club style.


Tequila Shrimp – 4 large shrimp, sautéed with tequila, garlic, butter and a touch of lime $14

Calamari & Banana Peppers – calamari and banana pepper slices, deep fried, served with cocktail sauce $9

Stuffed Mushrooms – large mushroom caps filled with crab and cheese, topped with hollandaise $9

Jerk Chicken Quesadilla – with sour cream and salsa $9

Chicken Wings – regular or hot $9

Fried Onion Stack – with chipotle ranch dipping sauce $8

Cheese Curds – battered and deep fried white cheddar curds $8

Louisiana Alligator Sausage – grilled on a skewer and served with barbecue sauce $6

Soup and Salad 

Add loaf of fresh baked bread $3. Add chicken to any salad $5. Anchovies $2. Blue cheese crumbles $3.

Homemade Soup of the Day – cup $3 / bowl $4

Clam Chowder (Friday only) – cup $4 / bowl $5

House Salad – mixed greens, tomato, cucumber, onion, croutons, shredded cheddar cheese $6

Spinach Salad – fresh spinach and mushrooms, hard boiled egg, real bacon, onion with hot bacon dressing $7

Caesar Salad – romaine lettuce, tomato, black olives, pepperoncini, onion, croutons with Parmesan Caesar dressing $7

Chicken Caesar Salad – a double portion of our Caesar Salad with grilled chicken $14

Soup and Salad – all you can eat $14

Seasonal Menu : Fall & Winter 2016/2017

Introducing a menu that changes with the seasons - using fresh ingredients, unique flavors and local products. 
You’ll find French and Mediterranean influences in Chef Ben’s creations that complement our traditional Wisconsin supper club fare along the shores of Lake Wisconsin. 

Seasonal Starters/Salads do not include soup, side salad or bread. Add: cup of soup $2. Fresh baked bread $3.

Braised Beef Short Rib Tacos – Two tacos with cabbage, daikon radish, queso fresco and salsa verde. $8

Oysters Rockefeller – Six traditionally prepared oysters with spinach mixture, parmesan, breadcrumbs, finished with our smoked tomato hollandaise. $14

Crab Cake with Saffron Aioli & Slaw – One 4 oz. sweet corn crab cake with saffron aioli served with fennel and daikon radish slaw. $13  (Add crab cake $5/each)

Waldorf Salad with Walnut Crusted Chicken – Fresh mixed greens, champagne poached fuji apple, golden raisins, chopped celery, creamy balsamic dressing and a walnut crusted chicken breast. $14

Seasonal Dinners include choice of salad or cup of soup and fresh baked bread.

Scallops with White Truffle Mushroom Butter – Five pan-seared scallops served with sautéed spinach and mushroom risotto. $28

Mediterranean Tortellini & Shrimp or Chicken – Three jumbo shrimp and tri-color cheese tortellini served with artichokes, kalamata olives, and sun-dried tomatoes in seafood cream sauce. $24  (Substitute grilled chicken breast for shrimp, $20)

Braised Beef Short Ribs – House braised short ribs served with mashed potatoes, rum glazed carrots, and red wine demi-glace. $22


Served with choice of salad or cup of soup, potato choice, and fresh baked bread. Upgrade to bowl of soup $1 (clam chowder $2).
Add .50 for cheese, onion, sour cream or applesauce with potato.

Jumbo Shrimp – beer battered, broiled and served with drawn butter, or scampi $27

Alaskan Red King Crab Legs – one pound of split legs and claws served with drawn butter $39

Seafood Platter: Haddock, Scallops, Shrimp and Alaskan Red King Crab – beer battered or broiled $45

Walleye Pike – beer battered or broiled $22

Icelandic Haddock
3 piece (12 oz.) beer battered $18 
2 piece (8 oz.) beer battered $14 
Broiled (12 oz.) $19 (add toasted almonds & hollandaise over rice to broiled choice for $1. No potato.)



Served with choice of salad or cup of soup, potato choice, and fresh baked bread. Upgrade to bowl of soup $1 (clam chowder $2).
Add .50 for cheese, onion, sour cream or applesauce with potato. 
Our steaks are fresh, never frozen, and charbroiled to your temperature. 

Add: Fresh sliced mushrooms sautéed with butter and garlic $5. Blue cheese $3. Béarnaise sauce $2.

Add seafood: Jumbo Shrimp $4/each. Scallop $4/each. Prawn $6/each. Crab Leg $12/each. Crab Cake with Béarnaise $5/each.

*Filet Mignon – 6 oz. $25

*16 oz. Ribeye – charbroiled to your temperature with garlic parsley butter, served with potato choice. $29

*Sirloin Hamburger Steak – ¾ lb. ground sirloin served with thick cut grilled onions $14

Pork Chops – two grilled 10 oz. pork chops $18

Baby Back Pork Ribs – flame broiled, slow roasted and marinated in our BBQ sauce Full $26 / Half $18

Broasted Chicken4-piece, includes breast, thigh, wing and leg $14; 2-piece, dark meat (white meat add $2) $10


Served with fresh baked bread. Choice of sauce: marinara, alfredo or pesto. Add chicken, shrimp, or sausage $5.

Cheese Tortellini – filled with a blend of cheeses $12

Mushroom Ravioli – filled with portobello mushrooms $15

Macaroni and Cheese – house made with a hint of truffle oil $7

All-You-Can-Eat Pasta – your choice of fettuccine or linguini, in marinara, alfredo or pesto sauce $10


All sandwiches include french fries. Add a cup of soup for $2.
Hamburgers are half-pound hand-pattied ground sirloin, charbroiled to your temperature.

*Classic Burger – with lettuce, onion and tomato. (Add any cheese, bacon or mushrooms for $1) $10

*Sharp White Cheddar Burger – with onion straws and barbecue sauce $11

*The Most Important Burger – with hashbrowns, cheese, onions, over-hard egg, bacon & maple mayo $11

Prime Rib French Dip – slow roasted Prime Rib, thinly sliced, served with au jus $11

Grilled Chicken Sandwich – with lettuce, tomato and mayonnaise $9

Deep Fried Haddock Sandwich – 4 oz. haddock with lettuce and tartar sauce $9

Blackened Mahi Mahi BLT – 4 oz. blackened mahi mahi, cherrywood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato $11


Thin Crust Cheese Pizza 10-inch $9 / 14-inch $13

Meat toppings (10-inch +$2 / 14-inch +$4): sausage, pepperoni, Canadian bacon, bacon, alligator sausage, chicken. 

Other toppings (10-inch +$1.25 / 14-inch +$2):  onion, green pepper, fresh mushrooms, tomatoes, black olives, green olives, pepperoncini, jalapeño, pineapple.

Specialty Pizzas (10-inch $16  /  14-inch $21):

Vegetable Pizza – artichoke, spinach, tomato, onion, green pepper, black olives & mozzarella.

Chicken and Bacon Pizza – chicken, bacon, fresh spinach and artichoke with alfredo sauce.

Chicken Alfredo Pizza – barbecued chicken, alligator sausage, fresh spinach, white cheddar, mozzarella and alfredo sauce.

Sunday thru Thursday Dinner Specials

All dinner specials served with fresh baked bread. Any substitutions add $1.

Bacon-wrapped Meatloaf – with gravy, crispy fried onion straws, homemade mashed potato, $11

*6 oz. Flat Iron Steak– with homemade mashed potatoes and vegetable $14

Broasted Chicken – with homemade mashed potatoes and vegetable (all white meat add $2) 2pc $8 / 4pc $12

*10 oz. Pork Chop – grilled chop with cup of soup or salad and potato choice $10

2 Deep Fried Shrimp – with cup of soup or salad and potato choice $11

Minnow Menu

For the kids. Add fries for $2.

Homemade Mac & Cheese $5

Chicken Tenders (2) $5

Mini Pepperoni Pizza $4

Grilled Cheese Sandwich $3

Kid’s Burger (add cheese $1) $4

Menu and prices subject to change.

* Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness.